CO129-124 - Sir MacDonnell - 1867 [8-9] — Page 364

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Lieut. May's remarks on the whole are entitled to much consideration, but whether his opinions are applicable is another matter.

That certain rules prima facie seem applicable where entire preoccupation will exist or certain tasks are recorded. Sir R. Macdonell's views cannot be prejudged. In Cha Su di fat p.38, it was decided that Hardull's interrogatories required some explanation.

One of the grounds declared the inapplicability of penal labour principles and matters related to local courts. The deferment of matters which I found that his opinion that prison discipline had a great effect appeared prima facie to be generally applicable. The separation of lifeguard prisoners and the system rebuked by the men when the Larden worked than tread-mill or shot-drill during their work (in 1865) was noted.

It was added that the Bread Wheel and the crank were used.

Edit History

2026-05-19 21:38:51 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Lieut. May's remarks on the whole are entitled to much consideration, but whether his opinions are applicable is another matter. That certain rules prima facie seem applicable where entire preoccupation will exist or certain tasks are recorded. Sir R. Macdonell's views cannot be prejudged. In Cha Su di fat p.38, it was decided that Hardull's interrogatories required some explanation. One of the grounds declared the inapplicability of penal labour principles and matters related to local courts. The deferment of matters which I found that his opinion that prison discipline had a great effect appeared prima facie to be generally applicable. The separation of lifeguard prisoners and the system rebuked by the men when the Larden worked than tread-mill or shot-drill during their work (in 1865) was noted. It was added that the Bread Wheel and the crank were used.
Baseline (Original)
Lie R. May them the Whole Sin R. Macdonnell's opinions faction of are entitled to munch cen sideration, but Whether his ве 7 That terms V. 2356 secing to portion of long be rules prin facie to geen Aplicabilly whereon entire preoccupation will tags exist or cer is recorebl apded. Si R. Macdonelle orn vieno awessouble cannot will be predecesour in Cha requati bi pro= Su di fat p.38. decided without some explanathardull's interrogatories Which to promised that separchia & و 2 of the grounds declares the inapplicable & shirt penal labour oldu. local curtes, principles & mater ried the deferaturant Maits which I ford that his opinion that 9 prisar disciplini great effect appear prime ficie to besparation atten a generally applicable. The sepurge Elia Prisoners & that they system & Reborn by the mendohen the Larden worked than treadshaught th Shot-drill duristen he werk (in 1865) they the the It was added that the Bread Wheel the crank L
2026-05-19 21:38:51 · Baseline
View content

Lie R. May them

the Whole

Sin R. Macdonnell's opinions faction of are entitled

to munch cen

sideration, but Whether his

ве

7

That terms V. 2356

secing to

portion of long be rules prin facie to geen Aplicabilly whereon entire preoccupation will tags exist or cer

is recorebl apded. Si R. Macdonelle

orn

vieno

awessouble cannot will be predecesour

in

Cha

requati

bi pro=

Su di fat p.38.

decided without some explanathardull's interrogatories

Which to

promised that separchia &

و

2 of the grounds declares the inapplicable &

shirt penal labour oldu. local curtes, principles & mater

ried

the deferaturant Maits which I ford that his opinion that 9 prisar disciplini

great effect appear prime ficie to besparation atten a generally applicable. The sepurge Elia Prisoners & that they system & Reborn by the mendohen the Larden worked than

treadshaught th Shot-drill duristen he werk (in 1865) they the the

It was added that the Bread Wheel

the crank

L

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.